Skip to content
AvailableMax

Overview

  • Updated On:
  • 07/06/2026
  • 128598
  • Property ID
  • 1 ft2
  • Property Lot Size
  • 4
  • Bedrooms
  • 6
  • Bathrooms
  • 3,412 ft2
  • Property Size
  • 1850
  • Year Built:
  1. Home
  6. 4-Bedroom Single Family Home for Rent in Sag Harbor, NY 11963 – $20000/mo | 6 Baths | Updated 2025
Sold
Single-family

4-Bedroom Single Family Home for Rent in Sag Harbor, NY 11963 – $20000/mo | 6 Baths | Updated 2025

$ 20,000
311 Main St, Sag Harbor
Favorite
Print

Description

Discover this stunning waterfront estate on Captain’s Row, where historic charm meets modern luxury. Overlooking scenic Otter Pond, this fully restored home offers 4 bedrooms, 5.5 baths, and a pool house, all just a short stroll from Sag Harbor Village. Inside, elegant furnishings and curated artwork enhance every space. The light-filled living and dining area features a cozy fireplace, while the chef’s kitchen boasts a breakfast bar, dining area, and open-hearth fireplace. For laid-back lounging, enjoy the den with a large-screen TV and pond views or retreat to the study, perfect for remote work. Upstairs, the primary suite stuns with water views, a spa-like bath and its own washer/dryer, a fireplace, and private terrace. Your guests will enjoy one of three beautifully appointed, sunny, and bright guest rooms. Outside, rolling lawns lead to the heated pool and spa, framed by an expansive patio, pool house with bath, and a studio with office space, making it a perfect setting for summer activities. Step into your dream Sag Harbor summer, in the heart of the Village, and minutes from Ocean beaches! Also available from December 20-January 2: 20K and June 12-19: 20K

AvailableMax local paths

Explore this market on AvailableMax

City archive Sag Harbor Property type Single-family State market New York

Address: 311 Main St
City:
State/County:
Zip: 11963
Country: United States
Open In Google Maps

Property Id: 128598
Price: $ 20,000
Property Size: 3,412 ft2
Property Lot Size: 1 ft2
Bedrooms: 4
Bathrooms: 6
Year Built: 1850

Energy Class: A+
Energy class A+
A+
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
AvailableMax Intelligence

Neighborhood & Market Insights

List price $20,000 Current property price
Price per sq ft $5.86 3,412 sq ft listed
Area median $31,500 32 comparables
Internal estimate $47,166 - $53,187 Based on area price per sq ft
School district 1 school Provider ready
Walkability & Transit Ready for data
Walk Score Connect location Uses the existing Walk Score setup
Transit Score Pending Shown when Walk Score returns transit coverage
Location signal Sag Harbor 311 Main St, 11963, Sag Harbor, New York
Open Walk Score
Neighborhood Market Strong sample
Median list price $31,500
Median price per sq ft $14.71
Trend lens Current active inventory
Valuation source Internal market model
This property $20,000
Area median $31,500
Estimate lens $50,176

This property is 36.5% below the current neighborhood median.

Price History Listing timeline
12/14/2025 Listed $20,000
07/06/2026 Last updated $20,000
Schools & District Provider ready
Schools Sag Harbor Ready for school data provider mapping.

The schools block is active and ready for district, ratings, and assigned-school provider data.

Estimated Value History Trend ready
12/14/2025 Listing baseline $20,000
07/06/2026 AvailableMax estimate range $47,166 - $53,187

150.9% modeled change across available points

Sag Harbor New York 11963
Data sources
Walk Score setup AvailableMax active listings AvailableMax market model School metadata Listing and valuation history

$ 136.87
per month
  • Principal and Interest
  • Property Tax
  • HOA fee
$ 111.87

Transport
Supermarkets
Schools
Restaurants
Pharmacies
Hospitals

Property Reviews

No reviews found.
You need to login in order to post a review

Similar Listings

Property Image
Sold

4-Bedroom Single Fam...

·
4 Bedrooms · 4 Bathrooms · Size 2,800 ft2
$ 85,000
Property Image
Sold

4-Bedroom Single Fam...

·
4 Bedrooms · 6 Bathrooms · Size 5,000 ft2
$ 12,500
Alma Gracia Alma Gracia
Sponsored

United Group Real Estate

Homes, seller support, and property opportunities from a dedicated real estate company.

Visit website
List your property on AvailableMax — fast, free, and built for serious exposure. Create Listing

Important Listing Information

Property ID: 128598

Property Address: 311 Main St, Sag Harbor, New York, 11963

Property details, pricing, availability, photos, dimensions, neighborhood information, and energy-related data may be provided by the property owner, listing agent, user submissions, or third-party data sources. Information may change without notice and should be independently verified before making any real estate, financial, or legal decision.

AvailableMax is a U.S.-based real estate technology platform that enables listing visibility and direct connections between users. AvailableMax does not represent buyers, sellers, landlords, or tenants in real estate transactions, and does not provide brokerage, legal, lending, or closing services unless expressly stated otherwise.

Photos, media, and listing content may be uploaded by users or supplied by third-party sources. Availability, accuracy, completeness, ownership, and usage rights of submitted materials are the responsibility of the submitting source.

Energy-related metrics and similar property attributes may be estimate-based or source-provided and may not reflect official governmental or certified assessments.

Data last updated: July 6, 2026 — 3:15 AM

Compare Listings

4-Bedroom Single Family Home for Rent in Sag Harbor, NY 11963 – $20000/mo | 6 Baths | Updated 2025

Want to find out more?

Contact Me

Alma Gracia